What Indianapolis Local Cuisine Should You Try?

As the Crossroads of America, Indianapolis is home to a wealth of exotic and delicious dishes for every kind of palatte. With flavors from around the world, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Here is a list of the seven local dishes you should try in Indianapolis, including some locations where you can sample them.

Breaded Pork Tenderloin

The classic Indiana staple, breaded pork tenderloin remains a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The secret is in the marinating and the breading. The pork loins are dipped in a combination of buttermilk and eggs before being coated in a mixture of cornmeal and flour seasoned with paprika, garlic powder, and other spices. Then they’re deep-fried giving them a crunchy crust and juicy interior.The Hoaglin To Go cafe at 390 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis is renowned for their pork tenderloines. It is commonly served on a sandwich with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

Fried Brain Sandwich

This unique sandwich has been a popular dish in the Midwest since the mid-1800s. It’s an Indo-Germanic recipe consisting of small sections of brain that are battered and fried before being served on toast with condiments such as horseradish and pickles. A classic fried brain sandwich can be found at The Grand Junction Brewing Company on 116th Street. It’s served on marbled rye with their special sauce, smoked onion rings, and melted provolone cheese.

Hoosier Stew

This hearty main course dish is said to have originated from pre-Civil war Indiana when families had to make the most out of whatever ingredients they found either from their farms or scraps they could find in the wild. It includes all local ingredients like potatoes, carrots, celery, beef and pork, hominy and tomatoes, beans and dumplings. Hoosier Stew can be found at The Whistle Stop Inn in Indianapolis. They’ve been serving it for over 60 years and their recipe is sure to satisfy your cravings for comfort food.

Indianapolis Sapper

This unique combination of pork tenderloin fried in beer batter and topped with steak sauce, pickles, and onions was created at an early-twentieth century pub called A&W Brewpub at 898m North Meridian Street in Indianapolis. The pub is no longer open but their award-winning sandwich lives on in local restaurants across town like Cap’n Ron’s on 700 North Shadeland Avenue.

Indianapolis-Style Pizza

Indianapolis-style pizza stands out for its thin crust expertly topped with melted cheese and robust, flavorful toppings like Italian sausage and pepperoni. This style originated from Nick’s English Hut restaurant at 423 East Kirkwood Avenue—a meetup spot back in the ’60s—where they served square slices that featured a thinner crust and fresh, homemade ingredients. Today these square slices are still popular with locals who love its unique flavor profile.

Award-Winning Pulled Pork Sandwich

Bar-B-Q Shack on 3265 West 16th Street has been serving some of the best smoked meats in Indianapolis for more than 20 years. Their signature item: the pulled pork sandwich. Piled high with juicy pork that has been slow-roasted then hand-pulled off the bone, it truly puts them a cut above the rest in town!

Bacon Buster Burger

If you’re looking for an unforgettable burger experience look no further than Shaka’s on 114 North Pennsylvania Street. Pound for pound no burger tops the Bacon Buster in Indianapolis—it’s a half-pound burger loaded with bacon and fries, then smothered in 10 ounces of cheese and special sauce. From classic staples like the pork tenderloin to extravagant indulgences like Indianapolis’s Bacon Buster Burger, there’s something for everyone to enjoy when it comes to Indy’s local cuisine. Whether you’re a native or a visitor, there’s nothing quite like experiencing the flavorful fare available in Indianapolis. There are plenty of restaurants throughout Indy that serve unique dishes perfect for your next adventure!

An Insider’s Guide to Indianapolis: Where Local Cuisine is Treated Like Royalty

Indianapolis, fondly called Indy, is more than just the state capital of Indiana, it is a place filled with rich cultural experiences, fascinating history, and of course, delicious cuisine. For any food lover or adventurer looking for an off-the-beaten-path experience, there is plenty to explore in this Midwestern city. Here’s an insider’s guide to the best places to experience the vibrant local culture and tantalizing cuisine.

Hidden Gems: Off-the-Path Attractions to Explore

Beyond the Indianapolis Motor Speedway and the Children’s Museum of Indianapolis, the city hides so many off-the-path attractions waiting for you to explore. One of the hidden gems is the Crown Hill Cemetery and Nature Preserve, home to historic gravesites and offering a serene atmosphere. The White River State Park is also another local favorite, with beautiful green spaces, museums, and water sports that provide an escape from the hustle and bustle of the city.

Dining Spots: Savoring Indy’s Rich Cuisine Culture

No trip to Indy is complete without indulging in some local cuisine. The city is famous for its tenderloin sandwiches, pork tenderloin cutlets breaded and fried to perfection, and surprisingly larger than the bun. For a sweet treat, the DeBrand Fine Chocolates is a must-visit, offering a wide array of chocolate treats that you will surely love. The Indianapolis City Market or the Milktooth Restaurant & Bakery are great places to try out diverse Indy food culture, including locally sourced ingredients and vegan-friendly dishes.

Cultural Experiences: Uncovering Indy’s Soulful Traditions

Indy is a place that takes pride in its cultural heritage and diversity. For a taste of the city’s artistic and cultural events, you can visit the Indiana State Museum and the Eiteljorg Museum of American Indians and Western Art, both showcasing impressive exhibitions from Native American arts to contemporary masterpieces. Immerse yourself in Indy’s music scene at the Jazz Kitchen, where local and national jazz acts perform throughout the year. Some festivals held annually, like the IndyFringe Theater Festival and the Cultural Trail Food Tours, perfectly showcase the rich culture and traditions that Indy has to offer.

Local History: Fascinating Stories of the Past

Indianapolis has a rich history that dates to the early 19th century. The famous Madame CJ Walker, America’s first self-made female millionaire, was born in Indy, and her mansion is open for tours. The Indiana War Memorial Plaza is another spot to explore the city’s military history and honor those who served the United States. Don’t miss the famous Graffiti Alley, located in an alleyway behind a restaurant in Fountain Square, where local street artists create colorful murals that tell the city’s story.

Off-the-Beaten-Path Suggestions: Unforgettable and Unique Experiences

Experience Indy from a different angle by taking a hot air balloon ride or visit the Lucas Oil Stadium, home to the Indianapolis Colts, on a non-game day. You can also visit the Indianapolis Motor Speedway Museum on a race day to get an insider’s perspective of the legendary racing culture. For something more relaxing, visit the Indianapolis Arts Garden, a tranquil rooftop garden with a striking view of the downtown Indy skyline.

In conclusion, Indianapolis is a Midwestern gem that will captivate the adventurous and curious traveler. From traditionally savory pork tenderloin sandwiches to contemporary art festivals, Indy’s offerings span history, culture, and food. Follow our insider’s guide to experience a truly unforgettable trip to Indianapolis.